Difference between Amish Paste Tomato, Roma, and San Marzano

There is a wide range of tomatoes in the market. You will find that each variety has a difference from the others. You can make sauces or cook with any type of tomato you want. However, you should expect certain differences in the paste or food you make depending on the type of tomato used.

purblack shilajit banner

Amish paste tomatoes, Roma, and San Marzano are among the most popular varieties of tomato. When comparing Amish paste tomatoes vs. Roma vs. San Marzano, you will notice distinct features.

Our post today covers the comparison between these three popular varieties of tomatoes. Let’s see what the difference is between them.

Amish Paste Tomatoes Overview

Amish Paste Tomatoes

Amish paste tomatoes are a type of tomato that came from Wisconsin. Normally, they are used in recipes. However, they have a sweetness that you can enjoy when eating them raw. Normally, they are used in making paste or sauce. If you need tomatoes that you can puree into a soup, this is the tomato for you.

Roma Tomatoes Overview

Roma Tomatoes

This is a hybrid type of tomato. It was developed around 1955. They have a structure similar to an egg with a length of around 3 inches.

They are a perfect variety for people who need a crunch. Compared to most tomato varieties, they have fewer seeds.

Roma tomatoes have a deep red color and a thicker flesh than other tomato varieties, which makes them perfect for making sauces and pastes. Their taste is more acidic and less sweet than other tomato varieties, which makes them perfect for savory dishes.

San Marzano Overview

San Marzano

San Marzano tomatoes are a type of heirloom tomato that originated from the San Marzano region of Italy. They are medium in size and have an elongated shape. San Marzano tomatoes have a deep red color and a thinner flesh than other tomato varieties, which makes them perfect for making sauces and pastes. Their taste is sweeter and less acidic than other tomato varieties, which makes them perfect for tomato-based sauces.


Amish Paste Tomato vs. Roma

Is Amish paste a Roma tomato? Well, one of the similarities between these two is that they are used to make paste or sauce. Even so, they have some key differences.

Roma tomatoes have a somewhat cylindrical shape, while the Amish paste tomatoes have a heart and round shape. Additionally, Roma tomatoes are normally bright red, while you can find Amish tomatoes in a range of colors.

Amish paste tomatoes also have an acidic flavor while Roma tomatoes are sweeter. Roma tomatoes are also crunchier with more flesh, which is not the same as Amish paste tomatoes.

Amish Paste Tomato vs. San Marzano

One thing that we know for sure is that the Amish paste tomato has a bit more flavor compared to San Marzano. But that is not the only difference there is.

You will also notice that the Amish-paste tomato is larger compared to the San Marzano. When making some sauce, you will require a bit more San Marzano to fill a jar compared to the Amish paste tomatoes. Additionally, it takes less effort to skin the San Marzano than the Amish paste tomatoes.

San Marzano vs. Roma

These two are low-moisture types of tomatoes. However, the San Marzano is a bit pointier and longer. It also has two seed chambers only.

While Roma tomatoes have a highly acidic flavor, the San Marzano is only slightly acidic.

Which Tomato Variety to Use?

The choice of tomato variety ultimately depends on what you are cooking and your personal preference. If you are making a sauce or paste, you may want to use Roma or San Marzano tomatoes due to their thicker flesh and sweeter taste.

f you are making a soup or stew, you may want to use Amish Paste tomatoes due to their meaty texture and fewer seeds. Each tomato variety has its unique flavor and texture, which can make all the difference in your dishes.


Understanding the differences between Amish Paste, Roma, and San Marzano tomatoes is essential for any tomato enthusiast or gardener. Each tomato variety has its unique characteristics that make it stand out from the others, and choosing the right one for your recipe or garden can make all the difference.

Amish Paste tomatoes are a meaty, flavorful variety that is perfect for making sauces and pastes. Roma tomatoes, on the other hand, are firm and less juicy, making them ideal for canning and preserving. San Marzano tomatoes are an Italian heirloom variety known for their sweet taste and low acidity, making them a popular choice for tomato sauces.

When it comes to growing these varieties, each has its specific requirements. Amish Paste tomatoes prefer a warm and humid environment, while Roma tomatoes do well in both warm and cooler climates. San Marzano tomatoes thrive in hot and dry weather.

The key to success with any of these tomato varieties is to provide them with the right growing conditions, including plenty of sun, well-draining soil, and regular watering. By doing so, you can enjoy a bountiful harvest of delicious, homegrown tomatoes.

Also, read: Difference Between Tomatillos And Ground Cherries

Now that you know the differences between Amish Paste, Roma, and San Marzano tomatoes, which one will you choose to grow in your garden or use in your next recipe? Let us know in the comments below!

Noom 4

Leave a Comment