Worcestershire Sauce vs Soy Sauce

Worcestershire and soy sauce are dark sauces that are rich in flavor. This flavor is reliant on fermentation. Worcestershire sauce, however, has a flavor that is more complex due to the use of a larger variety of ingredients compared to soy sauce.

Most enthusiasts consider the possibility of interchanging one sauce for the other. If you are one of those people, you are probably questioning the difference between soy sauce and Worcestershire sauce. In this post, we will tackle the soy sauce vs. Worcestershire sauce topic, trying to differentiate the two and shedding a light on the possibility of the sauces being used interchangeably.

The History

Soy Sauce
Soy Sauce


These two sauces have different histories. There was a time in Asia when Buddhism gained major popularity. This popularity brought about a need for seasonings that were vegetarian-friendly. Soy sauce was originally made as a paste created using fermented grain.

Later, the mix was altered by a Zen priest using a mix of wheat and soy grain. Later, in the 1600s, a woman by the name of Maki Shige fled from her due to an incursion. She began a new life in Noda and she learned a method of brewing sauce that is similar to the one in our markets currently.

The Worcestershire sauce’s origins are traced to India. The first introduction to the market was in 1837. The product was sold in stores by Lea and Perrins, who also tried to encourage its use on ships. It was highly successful, which led to exports to other parts of the world.

The Ingredients

Is Worcestershire sauce the same as soy sauce in regards to the components used? Well, there is very little similarity in the ingredients in both these sauces. Soy sauce is produced using mashed soybeans, enzymes, salt, and wheat, which are fermented together. The fermentation takes a period of around six months.

In the Worcestershire sauce, there is vinegar, anchovies, onions, cloves, molasses, chili pepper, garlic, tamarind, and corn syrup. The result is a very distinct aroma. The one ingredient that is in both these sauces is salt.

Substituting one for the other

Worcestershire Sauce

Worcestershire sauce is made with fermented anchovies, which are seasoned with vinegar, ginger, cloves, tamarind, garlic, molasses, and other ingredients. The flavor is therefore complex and layered, mainly due to the variety of components included in the recipe, and the fermentation.

If you want to use Worcestershire to replace soy sauce, you should alter its complexity, mainly because the flavors in the sauce should not be in soy sauce. If you intend to replace the soy sauce to change the saltiness, you should use less Worcestershire sauce with an addition of some salt.

You can use soy sauce as a replacement for Worcestershire sauce if you do not have it, or if you want to remove the fish ingredient for a vegetarian. You will even find certain brands of Worcestershire using soy sauce as part of the ingredient. Therefore, you can easily add certain ingredients, such as molasses, ginger, and tamarind, to the soy sauce to mimic the flavor of Worcestershire sauce. Add a quarter a cup of water to some simmered and sliced ginger and pour the mixture into your soy sauce.

How much Worcestershire sauce should I substitute for soy sauce?

The amount you should substitute for soy sauce will depend on your personal preferences and the recipe you are using.

If you are looking for a Worcestershire sauce substitute because you are allergic to soy, there are many options available. You can find Worcestershire sauce that is made without soy, or you can experiment with other sauces such as fish sauce, and tamari.

When substituting Worcestershire sauce for soy sauce in a recipe, start by substituting 1 tablespoon of Worcestershire sauce for every 2 tablespoons of soy sauce. From there, you can adjust the amount to suit your taste. Keep in mind that Worcestershire sauce is really a condiment, so you may need to add a little extra ingredient to balance out the flavors.


Is soy sauce and Worcestershire sauce the same? The truth is that they are not similar in any manner. However, a few alterations will allow you to interchange one for the other.


Feel free to share your observations with me in the comments section!

Also, if you find the information in this post to be useful, be sure to share this post with your friends on Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest!

Leave a Comment